
JJ Safety recently collaborated with Ultra-Safe Inc., a Phoenix, Arizona-based manufacturer of fall protection and height safety equipment, to get a firsthand look at how different fall protection systems perform in real-world demonstrations.
Ultra-Safe takes fall protection demonstrations to another level with a specialized drop-test trailer designed to put safety equipment to the test. The setup is simple but effective: a winch raises a 200+ pound weight into position, a pin is pulled, and gravity takes over. The result? A real-time demonstration of how different fall protection systems perform when a fall occurs.
During our visit with Franklin Sharp and his team, JJ Safety wanted to put a question many safety managers encounter to the test: What's the difference between a restraint lanyard, a shock-absorbing lanyard, and a Self-Retracting Lifeline (SRL)?
Using the same weight and testing setup, we watched three different systems demonstrate three very different outcomes.
In this article, we'll break down what we observed, what OSHA requires, and what these differences mean when it comes to selecting the right fall protection equipment for your crew.
Demonstration Takeaway
During Ultra-Safe's demonstrations, we observed several important differences between the three fall protection systems. Here's what stood out:
- Restraint Lanyards Are Not Designed for Fall Arrest: Restraint systems are designed to prevent workers from reaching a fall hazard in the first place. Because they have little to no stretch, they are not intended to absorb the energy of a fall. Attempting to use a restraint lanyard for fall arrest can expose a worker to dangerously high forces. OSHA limits the maximum arresting force on an employee using a full-body harness to 1,800 pounds.
- Shock-Absorbing Lanyards Need Clearance: These lanyards are designed to reduce the forces experienced during a fall by deploying an energy-absorbing pack. However, that energy absorption requires additional distance. The pack can extend up to 3.5 feet, which must be accounted for along with the lanyard length, worker height, and required safety clearance.
- SRLs Help Minimize Fall Distance: Self-Retracting Lifelines (SRLs) work similarly to a seatbelt. The lifeline extends and retracts with the worker's movement, then locks when a sudden fall occurs. During our demonstration with Ultra-Safe, the SRL deployed approximately 24 inches, compared to approximately 42 inches for the shock-absorbing lanyard. This demonstrated how quickly an SRL can engage and help limit fall distance.
- Fall-Involved Equipment Must Be Removed From Service: Any fall protection equipment that has been subjected to fall arrest forces must be immediately removed from service.
Meet the Rig and Those Who Sew the Harness
Ultra-Safe is a family-owned fall protection manufacturer based in Phoenix, Arizona. According to Franklin, the company's story began in 1995 as an extension of a rigging shop, when his father decided to expand into manufacturing nylon slings. More than 30 years later, Ultra-Safe has grown into a domestic manufacturer of fall protection equipment, including harnesses, lanyards, and lifeline systems.
One thing that sets Ultra-Safe apart is what Franklin describes as being a "nylon house." Rather than using polyester, Ultra-Safe focuses on nylon because of its softer feel and flexibility against the skin. That's an important consideration when you think about how long workers wear their harnesses. For someone spending eight or nine hours a day in fall protection equipment, comfort isn't just a luxury; it's part of making sure the equipment is practical for everyday use.
How the Drop-Test Trailer Works
Ultra-Safe's demonstration trailer is intentionally simple. There aren't complicated computer programs or elaborate testing displays. Instead, the setup uses a straightforward mechanical system to demonstrate how different fall protection products perform.
Here's how it works:
- Raise the weight: A winch mounted at the top of the trailer lifts the test weight approximately 15 feet into the air
- Release the weight: Once everything is positioned, a team member pulls the release pin
- Put the equipment to the test: A weight of just over 200 pounds, representing an approximate worker-and-tool-belt load, is released and allowed to free-fall approximately six feet
- See the results: By the time the lanyard engages, the weight is traveling approximately 13 mph, demonstrating the forces involved when a fall occurs
The concept is simple: raise the weight, release it, and let the equipment do its job.
No complicated software or elaborate displays. Just a weight, a fall protection system, and a demonstration that makes the differences between equipment much easier to understand.
Drop 1: The Restraint Lanyard (Fall Restraint vs. Fall Arrest)
A restraint lanyard has one job: keep a worker from reaching a fall hazard in the first place. It is designed to prevent a fall, not catch a worker after they've already gone over an edge. Franklin starts each jobsite demonstration with this drop to show why understanding that distinction is so important.
During the demonstration, the 200+ pound weight went from approximately 13 mph to a complete stop in just a couple of inches. Because a restraint lanyard has little to no energy-absorbing capability, it isn't designed to manage the forces generated during a fall. Instead, those forces can be transferred directly to the worker, potentially creating dangerously high arresting forces.
For comparison, OSHA limits the maximum arresting force on an employee using a personal fall arrest system with a full-body harness to 1,800 pounds. A restraint lanyard is not designed or intended to meet that requirement when used to arrest a fall.
This is why understanding the difference between fall restraint and fall arrest is critical. If a worker can reach the edge and potentially fall, a restraint lanyard is not the right equipment for the job. Restraint systems prevent workers from reaching the hazard. Fall arrest systems are designed to stop a fall after it happens. Knowing which system your crew needs can make all the difference.
Drop 2: The Shock-Absorbing Lanyard and Why Fall Clearance Matters
Before the second demonstration, Franklin handed the crew a shock-absorbing lanyard and asked a simple question: What's wrong with this piece of equipment? The answer? It had no label.
Even if the lanyard looked brand new and showed no visible signs of damage, the missing label meant its manufacturer, specifications, and intended use couldn't be verified. Without that information, the equipment should be removed from service until it can be properly identified and evaluated.
Then came the drop.
Using a four-foot shock-absorbing lanyard, the team repeated the demonstration with the same weight and six-foot free fall. This time, the energy-absorbing pack did exactly what it was designed to do. As Franklin described it, the tear-away webbing began ripping apart like a zipper, gradually slowing the weight and extending the stopping distance over several feet.
Instead of bringing the weight to an abrupt stop, the energy-absorbing pack helped reduce the forces experienced during the fall to a few hundred pounds.
But there's an important trade-off: the more distance the system needs to stop a fall, the more clearance the worker needs below them.
Why Fall Clearance Matters
Shock-absorbing lanyards need room to deploy. OSHA allows a maximum deceleration distance of 3.5 feet for applicable personal fall arrest systems, but that isn't the only distance employers need to consider.
Fall clearance calculations must account for:
- Lanyard length
- Maximum deceleration distance
- The worker's height
- And, additional safety clearance
For example, a simplified clearance calculation for a six-foot shock-absorbing lanyard might look like this:
6 ft lanyard + 3.5 ft deceleration + 6 ft worker height + 2 ft safety margin = 17.5 ft
Note: Actual clearance must account for the specific equipment, anchor location, connector stretch, deployment characteristics, and manufacturer's instructions.
That means a worker could need approximately 17.5 feet of clearance below the anchor point in this example. If there isn't enough room, the energy-absorbing pack could deploy exactly as designed, but the worker could still strike the level below.
A shock-absorbing lanyard can significantly reduce the forces experienced during a fall, but it needs enough clearance to do its job. Choosing the right equipment means looking beyond how well it catches a fall and considering what happens after it does.
And remember, once an energy-absorbing pack has deployed, that lanyard must be removed from service and must not be reused.
Drop 3: The Self-Retracting Lifeline (SRL)
The third demonstration featured a Self-Retracting Lifeline (SRL), a system that works much like a seatbelt. As a worker moves, the lifeline automatically extends and retracts, keeping slack to a minimum. When a sudden movement occurs, such as a fall, the internal braking mechanism engages and locks the line to help stop the fall.
During the demonstration, the SRL deployed approximately 24 inches before bringing the weight to a stop. For comparison, the shock-absorbing lanyard in Drop 2 required approximately 42 inches of deployment.
That difference is significant. A shorter stopping distance can help reduce the clearance needed below a worker and limit the distance they travel during a fall. However, the forces experienced by the worker still depend on the specific SRL, its design, and the conditions of the fall.
After the drop, Franklin pointed out another important detail: the SRL's rib stitching had pulled apart as the system absorbed the energy of the fall. This stitching is an important part of the equipment's design and can provide a visible indication that the system has experienced a fall event.
Just like a deployed shock-absorbing lanyard, an SRL that has arrested a fall must be immediately removed from service and must not be used again until it has been inspected and returned to service in accordance with the manufacturer's instructions.
When inspecting an SRL, workers should pay close attention to the condition of the lifeline, stitching, housing, connectors, and braking mechanism. Any damage, deployment indicators, or signs of a previous fall should be addressed before the equipment is used.
SRLs can be a great option when fall clearance is limited because they are designed to minimize slack and help reduce fall distance. But shorter deployment doesn't mean clearance calculations can be skipped. The right equipment, proper installation, regular inspections, and manufacturer requirements all play a role in keeping workers protected.
Restraint Lanyard vs. Shock-Absorbing Lanyard vs. SRL At a Glance
| Restraint Lanyard | Shock-Absorbing Lanyard | Self-Retracting Lanyard (SRL) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Purpose | Prevents workers from reaching a fall hazard | Arrests a fall after it occurs | Arrests a fall while minimizing lifeline slack |
| How It Works | Limits the worker's movement before reaching an edge | Uses a tear-away energy absorber to slow the fall | Automatically extends and retracts; locks during a fall |
| What We Saw in the Demonstration | Stopped the weight within a couple of inches | Energy-absorbing pack deployed and stretched the stopping distance | Braking mechanism engaged with approximately 24 inches of deployment |
| Energy Management | Not designed to absorb fall-arrest energy | Absorbs energy by deploying the shock pack | Uses an internal braking mechanism to control the fall |
| Fall Clearance | Designed to prevent a fall, not arrest one | Requires additional clearance for lanyard length, deceleration, and worker height | Typically requires less clearance than a comparable shock-absorbing lanyard, depending on the model |
| After a Fall | Not intended for fall arrest | Remove from service after deployment | Remove from service after arresting a fall |
The Dummy Drop: When to Remove a Harness From Service
The iron weight showed us how the lanyard responds to a fall. But to see what happens to the harness itself, we needed a body in it. As it turned out, Ultra-Safe had never dropped its training dummy from the rig before, making this a first for the team.
Before the drop, Franklin pointed out the harness’s load indicators, the specialized stitching designed to deploy when the harness is subjected to fall-arrest forces. Then we set up the test using the same SRL, the same drop, plus a full-body harness fitted to the dummy.
After the drop, the results were clear: the harness’s load-indicator stitching had fully deployed. It may have been in perfectly usable condition before the test, but after arresting a fall, it was no longer safe to use. One drop was all it took.
Any harness, lanyard, or SRL that has arrested a fall must be removed from service immediately, even if it appears undamaged. During routine inspections, always check load indicators and look for deployed stitching, torn or deployed energy absorbers, damaged components, and missing or unreadable labels. When fall protection equipment has been involved in a fall, follow the manufacturer’s instructions for inspection and replacement before it is ever considered for use again.
50-Plus Years of Fall Protection: How Far We've Come
Every rule behind those three drops was learned through experience, and sometimes the hard way. In the video, Destry from JJ Safety takes us through a quick history of how fall protection has evolved over the years:
In 1970, the OSH Act establishes OSHA. At the time, fall protection largely relied on body belts. While they offered some protection, they could also cause serious injury by concentrating the force of a fall on the waist and abdomen.
In 1998, body belts are officially phased out of personal fall arrest systems in construction, effective January 1. Full-body harnesses become the standard.
In 2007, ANSI Z359.1-2007 significantly increases snap hook and carabiner gate strength requirements, raising the minimum from 220 lbs to 3,600 lbs.
And, in 2025, OSHA's updated construction PPE rule takes effect January 13, explicitly requiring employers to ensure PPE properly fits each worker.
That last update is especially important when it comes to harness selection. A harness isn't doing its job if it doesn't fit properly. Comfort, proper adjustment, and fit all play a role in making sure workers actually wear their equipment correctly and consistently throughout the day.
FAQ: Common Questions Regarding Fall Protection
Q: What’s the difference between fall restraint and fall arrest?
A: Fall restraint prevents a worker from reaching a fall hazard in the first place, keeping them safely away from the edge. Fall arrest, on the other hand, is designed to stop a worker after a fall has already occurred.
The key difference? Fall restraint prevents the fall; fall arrest stops it. It's important to remember that restraint lanyards are not designed or rated to arrest a fall, so the two systems should never be used interchangeably.
Q: Can you use a restraint lanyard for fall arrest?
A: No. Restraint lanyards are designed to prevent a worker from reaching a fall hazard, not to stop them once a fall occurs. During our drop test, a restraint lanyard stopped more than 200 lbs. in just a few inches. That sudden stop can generate forces reaching thousands of pounds, potentially causing serious injuries. For comparison, OSHA limits the maximum arresting force on a worker using a full-body harness to 1,800 lbs.
Q: How much clearance does a shock-absorbing lanyard need?
A: A common rule of thumb for a 6-foot shock-absorbing lanyard is approximately 17.5 feet of clearance below the anchor point. That estimate accounts for:
- 6 ft: Lanyard length
- 3.5 ft: Maximum deceleration distance
- 6 ft: Average worker height
- 2 ft: Additional safety margin
Keep in mind that clearance requirements can vary depending on the equipment, anchor location, and setup. Always consult the manufacturer's specifications and calculate the required fall clearance before beginning work.
Q: Is an SRL better than a shock-absorbing lanyard?
A: It depends on the job and the conditions of the worksite. In our drop test, the Self-Retracting Lifeline (SRL) deployed approximately 24 inches, compared to about 42 inches for the shock-absorbing lanyard. That shorter deployment distance means an SRL may require significantly less fall clearance.
Shock-absorbing lanyards, on the other hand, are typically simpler, lighter, and can be a practical option for many applications.
Q: Do you have to replace a harness after a fall?
A: Yes. Any harness, lanyard, or SRL that has been subjected to fall arrest must be immediately removed from service. Even if the equipment appears undamaged, it may have sustained damage that compromises its ability to protect you in another fall.
Look for warning signs such as deployed load indicators, pulled or torn stitching, and deployed or damaged shock-absorbing packs.
Q: What does the 2025 OSHA PPE fit rule mean for harnesses?
A: Effective January 13, 2025, OSHA requires construction employers to ensure all PPE properly fits each individual worker. When it comes to fall protection, that means providing a harness that is the correct size and can be properly adjusted to fit the worker wearing it.
A properly fitted harness isn't just about comfort; it's essential to ensuring the equipment functions as intended and provides the protection workers need.
Wrap Up: Three Falls, Three Important Lessons
JJ Safety and Ultra-Safe put three different falls to the test, and the results reinforced three important lessons every worker and employer should understand:
- Restraint Isn't Arrest. A restraint lanyard should only be used to keep a worker from reaching a fall hazard. It is not designed to stop a fall.
- Know Your Fall Clearance. A shock-absorbing lanyard can only do its job if there is enough clearance below the worker for the system to fully deploy.
- Once It Catches a Fall, It's Done. Any harness, lanyard, or SRL that has arrested a fall must be removed from service. Inspect it, identify the warning signs, and never put it back into use.
Falls remain one of the leading causes of death in construction. In 2023, slips, trips, and falls accounted for 421 of the industry's 1,075 fatalities. Even more concerning, most fatal falls occurred from heights between 6 and 30 feet. That's exactly the range where understanding your equipment, choosing the right system, and knowing your clearance can make all the difference.
A huge thank you to Franklin and the crew at Ultra-Safe for sharing their knowledge and putting this equipment to the test. Their hands-on demonstrations help the rest of us understand the risks before learning these lessons the hard way.
Want your crew to see the difference before they’re on the edge? Talk to JJ Safety about fall protection training and toolbox talks! Interested in the fall protection equipment featured in these demonstrations? Check out what Ultra-Safe has to offer!

Brooklyn Nice
Brooklyn Nice is a Content Development Specialist at JJ Safety, where she creates engaging, OSHA-focused safety content, training materials, and educational resources for workers and employers. She has earned her OSHA 10 Certification, providing her with a strong foundation in workplace safety principles and industry best practices.


